134 Main St., ca. 1850
Designated May 16, 2006

Though probably built as an investment by Henry Butler, later owners included members of the local Totten family with ties to the oyster business. Theodore DeHart, an oyster planter, and his wife Elizabeth were the owner/occupants for nearly 40 years, from 1874 to 1913. 134 Main Street is one of the oldest houses on this important street.

NYC Landmarks Preservation Report